Published on: 30/03/2024
Sphere 3D-Gryphon Legal Battle: A New Twist in the Crypto-mining Saga
The turbulent tale of the legal dispute between Bitcoin miners, Sphere 3D and Gryphon Digital Mining, flared up once again on March 25. In a fresh turn of events, Gryphon has taken legal action, seeking to withhold $10 million from Sphere 3Ds recent settlement payout linked to Core Scientific’s bankruptcy exit.
In a pre-motion letter filed with the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, Gryphon has requested permission to file a motion for prejudgment attachment. The focus of this motion lies in securing the aforementioned sum, to ensure availability of the funds for any judgment Gryphon may receive owing to Spheres alleged breach of contract, accruing damages of at least $30 million.
The current legal debacle stems from allegations of Sphere entering into at least four hosting agreements with other service providers, in breach of the exclusivity stipulated in their contract with Gryphon. This violation has intensified the existing skirmish between the two mining houses, already at odds over prior litigation.
However, there is more to the brewing conflict than what meets the eye, especially concerning Spheres financial health. Based on Spheres annual report filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, and as per Gryphon’s pre-motion letter, Sphere has hinted at potential bankruptcy. Given the alluded fiscal instability, Gryphons move may well be a strategic safeguarding attempt to ensure claims, should legal assertions be legitimized.
Looking back to November 2023, records from the Core Bankruptcy Action highlight that Sphere was operating at a staggering $200 million net loss, with losses outpacing revenues at a 2:1 ratio. More recently, Spheres earnings report released on March 13, 2023, revealed a net loss of $23.4 million for 2023, a sharp fall from $192.8 million in the previous year. This decline could partly be attributed to the crypto winter, a period of profit drought that loosely aligns with the traditional financial markets concept of economic downturns.
Relations between Sphere and Gryphon, once potential merger partners, have been frosty since the allegation of a spoofing attack mid-2023 leading to an irregular Bitcoin transfer. Subsequent events saw allegations of negligence and even defamation thrown into the mix, further straining the rapport between the two entities.
From an investment perspective, this evolving legal conflict serves as a reminder of the volatile and unpredictable nature of the nascent Crypto market. Investors may need to factor in these industry spats while making calculated decisions. The fallout could serve as a significant risk indicator, possibly stirring market sentiment and influencing future movements. It also underlies the importance of robust legal frameworks within the Crypto market, helping to prevent such conflicts and protect stakeholder interests.
While we keenly observe the unfolding of these eventful developments, what will transpire next remains an intriguing question. We hang in anticipation, waiting to see how this lawsuit may ripple across the broader Crypto market. Stay tuned for further updates. Meanwhile, Sphere 3D hasnt yet issued an official response to the pre-motion letter.